FA Cup 2023/24, Third Round Proper |
 | 06.01.2024 |  | Plymouth Argyle | – | Sutton United | | 3:1 (1:0) |
| Plymouth |
FA Cup 2022/23, First Round Proper |
| 05.11.2022 | | Sutton United | – | Farnborough | | 0:2 (0:0) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2021/22, Second Round Proper |
| 04.12.2021 | | Bristol Rovers | – | Sutton United | | 2:1 (0:0) |
| Bristol |
FA Cup 2020/21, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| 24.10.2020 | | Sutton United | – | Bromley | | 0:1 |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2019/20, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| 22.10.2019 | | Billericay Town | – | Sutton United | | 5:2 (3:1) * |
| Billericay |
FA Cup 2017/18, First Round Proper |
| 05.11.2017 | | Cambridge United | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 (1:0) |
| Cambridge |
FA Cup 2016/17, Fifth Round Proper |
| 20.02.2017 | | Sutton United | – | Arsenal | | 0:2 (0:1) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2015/16, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| 24.10.2015 | | Aldershot Town | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 (0:0) |
| Aldershot |
FA Cup 2014/15, Third Qualifying Round |
| 11.10.2014 | | Sutton United | – | Burgess Hill Town | | 1:3 (0:1) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2013/14, First Round Proper |
| 09.11.2013 | | Kidderminster Harriers | – | Sutton United | | 4:1 (2:1) |
| Kidderminster |
FA Cup 2012/13, Second Qualifying Round |
| 22.09.2012 | | Sutton United | – | Bromley | | 0:1 |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2011/12, Second Round Proper |
| 04.12.2011 | | Sutton United | – | Notts County | | 0:2 (0:1) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2010/11, First Qualifying Round |
| 11.09.2010 | | Sutton United | – | Alton Town | | 1:2 |
| |
FA Cup 2009/10, First Round Proper |
| 07.11.2009 | | Hereford United | – | Sutton United | | 2:0 (1:0) |
| Hereford |
FA Cup 2008/09, First Round Proper |
| 08.11.2008 | | Sutton United | – | Notts County | | 0:1 (0:0) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 2007/08, Third Qualifying Round |
| 14.10.2007 | | Lewes | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 2006/07, Second Qualifying Round |
| 30.09.2006 | | Sutton United | – | Bishop's Stortford | | 1:3 |
| |
FA Cup 2005/06, Third Qualifying Round |
| 08.10.2005 | | Chippenham Town | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 2004/05, Third Qualifying Round |
| | | Bromley | – | Sutton United | | 2:1 * |
| |
FA Cup 2002/03, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Heybridge Swifts | | 1:2 * |
| |
FA Cup 2001/02, Third Qualifying Round |
| | | Aldershot Town | – | Sutton United | | 3:0 (2:0) |
| |
FA Cup 2000/01, Third Qualifying Round |
| | | Bath City | – | Sutton United | | 3:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1999/00, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Rushden & Diamonds | – | Sutton United | | 4:1 (3:0) |
| |
FA Cup 1998/99, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Boreham Wood | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1997/98, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Cheltenham Town | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1996/97, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Bromley | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1995/96, Second Round Proper |
| 02.12.1995 | | Hereford United | – | Sutton United | | 2:0 (1:0) |
| Hereford |
FA Cup 1994/95, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Marlow | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1993/94, Third Round Proper |
| 08.01.1994 | | Notts County | – | Sutton United | | 3:2 (2:0) |
| Nottingham |
FA Cup 1992/93, First Round Proper |
| 14.11.1992 | | Sutton United | – | Hereford United | | 1:2 (1:1) |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 1991/92, First Round Proper |
| 16.11.1991 | | Maidstone United | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| Dartford |
FA Cup 1990/91, First Round Proper |
| 21.11.1990 | | Sutton United | – | Merthyr Tydfil |  | 0:1 * |
| Sutton |
FA Cup 1989/90, First Round Proper |
| 22.11.1989 | | Torquay United | – | Sutton United | | 4:0 * |
| Torquay |
FA Cup 1988/89, Fourth Round Proper |
| 28.01.1989 | | Norwich City | – | Sutton United | | 8:0 (3:0) |
| Norwich |
FA Cup 1987/88, Third Round Proper |
| 12.01.1988 | | Middlesbrough | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 aet * |
| Middlesbrough |
FA Cup 1986/87, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Yeading | – | Sutton United | | 4:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1985/86, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Gravesend & Northfleet | | 0:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1984/85, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Grays Athletic | – | Sutton United | | 3:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1983/84, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Maidstone United | | 1:3 * |
| |
FA Cup 1982/83, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Wealdstone | – | Sutton United | | 3:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1981/82, Second Round Proper |
| 15.12.1981 | | Swindon Town | – | Sutton United | | 2:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1980/81, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Minehead | – | Sutton United | | 2:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1979/80, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Addlestone | | 0:3 * |
| |
FA Cup 1978/79, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Dartford | | 0:2 |
| |
FA Cup 1977/78, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Tooting & Mitcham United | – | Sutton United | | 3:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1976/77, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Barking | | 1:4 * |
| |
FA Cup 1975/76, First Round Proper |
| 26.11.1975 | | Bournemouth | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 * |
| |
FA Cup 1974/75, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Slough Town | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1973/74, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Leytonstone | – | Sutton United | | 3:2 |
| |
FA Cup 1972/73, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Margate | – | Sutton United | | 2:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1971/72, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Witney Town | | 0:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1970/71, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Walton & Hersham | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1969/70, Fourth Round Proper |
| 24.01.1970 | | Sutton United | – | Leeds United | | 0:6 (0:3) |
| |
FA Cup 1968/69, First Qualifying Round |
| | | Bexley United | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1967/68, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Barnet | – | Sutton United | | 3:1 * |
| |
FA Cup 1966/67, First Round Proper |
| 26.11.1966 | | Bath City | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1965/66, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Crawley Town | | 0:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1964/65, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Bexley United | – | Sutton United | | 3:1 * |
| |
FA Cup 1963/64, First Round Proper |
| 16.11.1963 | | Sutton United | – | Aldershot | | 0:4 |
| |
FA Cup 1962/63, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Gravesend & Northfleet | – | Sutton United | | 2:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1961/62, First Qualifying Round |
| | | Slough Town | – | Sutton United | | 4:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1960/61, First Round Proper |
| 09.11.1960 | | Romford | – | Sutton United | | 5:0 * |
| |
FA Cup 1959/60, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Hastings United | | 2:3 |
| |
FA Cup 1958/59, Third Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Tooting & Mitcham United | | 1:8 |
| |
FA Cup 1957/58, First Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Walton & Hersham | | 0:4 * |
| |
FA Cup 1956/57, Preliminary Round |
| | | Erith & Belvedere | – | Sutton United | | 4:3 |
| |
FA Cup 1955/56, Preliminary Round |
| | | Canterbury City | – | Sutton United | | 2:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1954/55, Preliminary Round |
| | | Canterbury City | – | Sutton United | | 3:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1953/54, Preliminary Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Deal Town | | 3:5 |
| |
FA Cup 1952/53, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Carshalton Athletic | | 0:2 |
| |
FA Cup 1951/52, Fourth Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Folkestone | | 1:3 * |
| |
FA Cup 1950/51, Preliminary Round |
| | | Tooting & Mitcham United | – | Sutton United | | 1:0 * |
| |
FA Cup 1949/50, Preliminary Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Kingstonian | | 0:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1948/49, Second Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Tooting & Mitcham United | | 0:1 |
| |
FA Cup 1947/48, First Qualifying Round |
| | | Sutton United | – | Carshalton Athletic | | 1:3 |
| |
FA Cup 1946/47, First Round Proper |
| 30.11.1946 | | Barnet | – | Sutton United | | 3:0 |
| |
FA Cup 1945/46, First Round Proper |
| 24.11.1945 | | Walthamstow Avenue | – | Sutton United | | 7:2 |
| |
FA Cup 1945/46, First Round Proper |
| 17.11.1945 | | Sutton United | – | Walthamstow Avenue | | 1:4 |
| |
